Comparison of Doctoral Programs: PhD, DHSc, and DNP

 

Dr. Emrick's Links

Kelly Emrick, PhD, MBA – Medium

I was asked to conduct a market analysis of three different doctoral-level programs. I reviewed 10 random programs from various universities. In the table below, I synthesized data from these sites and compiled common themes from the programs. The study of doctoral education in nursing and health sciences reveals significant variations in program duration, primarily influenced by the nature of the required scholarly output and the depth of methodological preparation. Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) programs in nursing and many Doctor of Health Science (DHSc) programs, particularly those emphasizing original research, involve a longer timeline, often spanning four to seven years post-baccalaureate or three to five years post-master's. This extended commitment is mainly due to the rigorous demands of producing a dissertation, a substantial piece of original research that requires comprehensive literature synthesis, complex methodological design (often involving primary data collection and advanced statistical analysis), and a novel contribution to the existing body of knowledge. The iterative process of conceptualization, proposal development, Institutional Review Board navigation, data acquisition, analysis, and scholarly writing in dissertation work significantly contributes to this duration. Conversely, the Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) is generally completed within a more condensed timeframe of 1.5 to 2.5 years, especially when pursued post-master's. This relative brevity stems from its focus on translating existing evidence into practice rather than generating new foundational knowledge. While a rigorous scholarly undertaking, the DNP project is typically more focused on applying, implementing, and evaluating evidence-based interventions or system changes within a defined context, thus often involving a more predictable trajectory. Ultimately, these differences in program length can indicate varying levels of overall intellectual challenge and time commitment, but reflect the programmatic goals, the specific nature of the terminal scholarly project, and the necessary depth of preparatory coursework for each degree's intended professional outcomes.

Feature	PhD (Doctor of Philosophy) in Nursing	DHSc (Doctor of Health Science)	DNP (Doctor of Nursing Practice)
Primary Focus	Original research, theory development, knowledge generation.	Applied research, leadership, education, or advanced practice in health sciences.	Translation of research into practice, clinical leadership, and systems improvement.
Typical Core Coursework Categories	- Philosophy of Science. Nursing Theory Development. Advanced Research Ethics- Health Policy (research implications).	- Health Systems & Policy. Leadership in Healthcare. Health Program Planning & Evaluation. Health Ethics. Interprofessional Collaboration.	- Evidence-Based Practice. Healthcare Policy & Advocacy. Health Informatics & Data Management. Leadership & Organizational Systems. Quality Improvement & Patient Safety Epidemiology & Biostatistics (applied).
Research/Methodology Courses	- Advanced Quantitative Methods- Advanced Qualitative Methods- Mixed Methods Research Design- Advanced Statistics (e.g., regression, multivariate analysis)- Measurement & Instrumentation- Grant Writing.	Varies by program focus: - Could be similar to a PhD if research-intensive (e.g., advanced quantitative/qualitative, stats). Present applied /practice-focused (e.g., program evaluation, applied stats).	- Research Appraisal & Translation- Biostatistics for Clinical Practice- Program Evaluation Methods- Quality Improvement Methodologies- Epidemiology (applied).
Specialization/Elective Courses	Generally, it requires a specific area of research interest (e.g., leadership, management, population, health condition, theoretical area), cognate courses outside nursing.	Courses related to concentration (e.g., Healthcare Administration, Population Health, Epidemiology, Health Education, Health System Leadership, Quality Outcomes).	Post-BSN Entry: Includes foundational MSN-level APRN or functional role courses (e.g., Advanced Pathophysiology, Pharmacology, Assessment, and specific population focus for NPs; or leadership/informatics core).Post-MSN Entry: Fewer, more focused on DNP essentials, leadership, or a particular area of practice refinement.
Culminating Project	Dissertation: Substantial original research study making a new contribution to nursing science.	Dissertation or Applied Research Project: Can be original research (often applied) or a significant scholarly project addressing a real-world health problem. Varies widely.	DNP Project: Practice-focused project demonstrating synthesis of evidence to design, implement, and evaluate a change in practice, QI initiative, or policy.
Typical Credit Hours (Post-Master's)	~60-70+ credits	~60-70+ credits	~30-35 credits
Typical Program Length (Post-Master's)	5-7 years	4-5 years	1.5-2.5 years
Estimated Total Program Work Hours (Approximate)	High: e.g., 3,000 - 5,000+ hours (coursework) + extensive dissertation hours (can be 1,000 or more).	Variable: Can range from DNP-like to PhD-like hours, e.g., 2,000 - 4,500+ hours.	Moderate to High: Post-MSN: ~1,500 - 2,500+ hours post-BSN: ~3,000 - 4,500+ hours.
Primary Career Outcomes	Healthcare leadership, research Scientist, University Faculty (research-intensive), Nurse Theorist, healthcare operations and management, quality expert, or policy expert.	Healthcare administrators, public health leaders, university faculty (practice/teaching-focused), health educators, and advanced clinicians in various health fields.	Advanced Practice Leaders (NP, CNS, CRNA, CNM), Nurse Executives, Quality Improvement Specialists, Clinical Faculty, Health Policy Analysts.