U.S. Hospitals Are at a Breaking Point

 

Dr. Emrick's Books, Blogs, and Podcasts

U.S. Hospitals Are at a Breaking Point

In 2020, I published a book titled Fiscal Fitness: Strengthening Hospital Financial Performance. In the book, I discuss the urgency of hospital leaders to pinpoint every source of revenue and where every dollar is being spent. It seems that we are quickly heading in this direction.  The U.S. hospital industry is caught in a financial storm that’s impossible to ignore. Flip through recent earnings reports—like those from Q3—and the story becomes clear: Many hospitals barely stay afloat, while others are drowning in losses. Some are merging or selling out to keep the lights on. It’s a chaotic, high-stakes moment reshaping how healthcare operates, who receives care, and what it might cost us. So, what’s driving this mess, and where are we headed? Let's unpack some financial reports I reviewed in the past week.

Hospitals aren’t grappling with a single issue; they’re being overwhelmed from every direction. Take labor costs, for instance. Nurses, technologists, and doctors are the lifeblood of any hospital and make up the biggest expense. After the pandemic, burnout drove many away or into early retirement, leaving gaps that hospitals filled with costly contract workers. Even as that reliance lessens, wages continue to soar because the competition for talent is intense. The latest quarterly reports emphasize this issue: labor costs are the primary reason budgets are exceeded. Notably,  everything else is increasing in price too—drugs, supplies, energy, you name it. Inflation’s taking a toll, but hospitals can’t raise prices like a coffee shop might. Their payments from Medicare, Medicaid, and insurers are fixed, often years in advance, so they’re left absorbing the difference when costs rise.

Then there’s the question of who is footing the bill. More patients are older and rely on Medicare, which pays less than private insurance, sometimes even less than the cost of their treatment. Economic pressures mean more individuals are on government plans or entirely uninsured, and this shift tightens revenue even further. Insurance companies aren’t making it easier, either. They employ harsh tactics such as denying claims or adding paperwork, which slows down cash flow and creates headaches. New regulations being discussed, like equal payments for hospital and outpatient care, could reduce income streams even further, particularly for the outpatient services that hospitals rely on. Patients themselves are altering the situation, too. While numbers might be returning to pre-pandemic levels, the demographic mix is different. Hospitals are encountering sicker patients who require more time and resources, more extended stays, and larger bills, but the payments don’t always reflect the effort involved. Simultaneously, more uncomplicated care is shifting to outpatient clinics or doctor’s offices, influenced by insurers and patient preferences. While this is cheaper in theory, it compels hospitals to invest heavily to keep pace, and if they don’t approach it wisely, they risk losing money on both fronts.

The proof of this mess isn’t hard to find; it’s right there in the numbers and the headlines. Earnings reports depict a grim picture: many hospitals are losing money on daily operations, with negative profit margins that only get supported by things like investment income or donations. Cash reserves are dwindling, leaving little cushion for surprises, and costs are rising faster than revenue with no end in sight. Meanwhile, the market is abuzz with mergers and acquisitions. Smaller hospitals, desperate for cash, are teaming up with larger players to survive. Large systems are acquiring others to grow stronger, expand, and negotiate better with insurers. Even outsiders like private equity firms and tech giants are jumping in, purchasing doctor groups or specific services, disrupting the traditional hospital playbook.

This isn’t just about money—it’s about rewriting the rules of healthcare. To survive, hospitals are making tough decisions: closing unprofitable services like maternity wards, laying off staff, or delaying upgrades. This can mean less care where it’s needed most, such as rural towns or underserved neighborhoods. Mergers might save some, but they’re creating giants that dominate markets, and regulators are beginning to express concern. They’re worried about higher prices, fewer choices, and potentially lower quality if competition diminishes. The hospitals hit hardest are often “safety-net” ones serving the poorest patients—those with significant Medicaid coverage or no insurance at all. If they shut down or are acquired by systems that don’t prioritize those communities, gaps in care could widen.

This crisis is a flashing red light: the traditional way of operating isn’t working. Hospitals can’t just cut costs and call it a day; they need to rethink everything. That might involve shifting to payment models that reward results over procedures, embracing technology and automation to work smarter, or forming new partnerships that extend beyond the usual mergers. The bottom line is stark: U.S. hospitals are caught between skyrocketing costs and stagnant revenues, and it’s reflected in their finances and the deal-making frenzy reshaping the industry. This could lead to a leaner, more efficient system or one where power consolidates, prices rise, and some communities suffer. Addressing this challenge will require strong leadership, more innovative policies on payments and mergers, and genuine support for hospitals serving the most vulnerable. We need to keep examining how this unfolds over time because healthcare is too critical to get wrong.