Tariffs: A Lesson in Economics

 

Dr Emrick's Books, Blogs, and Podcasts

So, what are tariffs? Tariffs are just what they sound like: taxes that a government charges on imported goods and services. The consumer of those goods pays higher prices for those tariffed products. Each of these levies raises the overall cost of imports, making foreign products less competitive against domestic goods. Historically, protectionist governments use tariffs to shield developing industries, save jobs, correct trade deficits, and occasionally for political leverage. The United States has been the world’s foremost advocate of free trade, slashing tariff barriers by 90 percent or more since the mid-20th century. Yet this openness has frequently resulted in asymmetric economic fallout, with those impacts primarily being felt by our trading partners who still have high tariffs on American exports. Funding for improved bilateral and multilateral enforcement, China has imposed significant tariffs and regulatory barriers on American products, creating an unlevel playing field. This imbalance has been a primary driver of the US trade deficit with China, which, by 2018, had reached a record high of $419 billion per year. President Trump argues that tariffs are the appropriate response to decades of imbalanced economic engagement. In short, the United States has been losing on every playing field to unfair foreign competition, especially from China. Trump’s administration sees tariffs as essential leverage to rework trade deals, strengthen domestic manufacturing capacity, and protect American livelihoods in industries hammered by global competition.

The administration’s long-term justification relies on two main premises. These benefits go beyond creating logistically centralized jobs, such as revitalizing manufacturing jobs, spurring domestic investment, and pushing countries like China to play by fair trade rules. By levying reciprocal tariffs, the United States seeks to create a more level economic playing field, promoting an economic context in which American workers, businesses, and the overall economy can thrive. Critics point to the threat of retaliatory actions, higher consumer costs, and chaos in world supply chains. Against these fears, advocates point to previous episodes in which carefully considered tariff policies have mitigated the risk of industrial decline, fueled innovation, and contributed to a more robust national economy. President Trump’s tariff policies are a bold, new economic direction to recalibrate decades of unfair financial practices and restore balance and fairness to America’s economic foundation to ensure the United States continues to thrive and succeed.

Over the past four decades, China's economic growth has been remarkable, positioning it as a leading global economic powerhouse. A significant factor contributing to China's rapid ascent has been its strategic use of tariffs and trade barriers, which have often disadvantaged international trade partners, including the United States. Historically, China has implemented high tariffs and stringent regulatory barriers on imported goods, protecting its domestic industries and enabling them to flourish without the pressures of significant foreign competition. This approach allowed China to nurture key sectors such as manufacturing, technology, and infrastructure, contributing substantially to its economic expansion.

In contrast, the United States, championing free trade policies since the mid-20th century, has often faced an uneven playing field. American industries frequently encounter substantial tariffs and regulatory hurdles when exporting products to China. China's use of tariffs extends beyond bilateral interactions with the U.S., impacting global trade dynamics broadly. Many other nations have similarly faced restrictive Chinese tariff policies, compelling international firms to establish operations within China to circumvent these trade barriers. Consequently, this strategy has effectively shifted the global economic balance, enhancing China's industrial and technological capacities at the expense of trading partners. When tariffs increase, the initial cost is typically borne by importing businesses. These businesses often pass this cost onto consumers through higher prices, effectively making imported goods more expensive. Consequently, tariffs can indirectly burden consumers, who ultimately pay the higher prices resulting from increased import costs.

Since the U.S. has been undergoing industrial growth for over two centuries, maintaining an open-market stance without reciprocal openness from China poses severe economic risks. Failure to address this imbalance may have substantial long-term consequences for U.S. economic growth, employment, and international competitiveness. The United States must, therefore, reconsider its tariff strategies, aiming to balance international trade relationships strategically. Addressing tariff imbalances is essential to ensure equitable global trade and protect and enhance America's industrial and economic growth prospects. Without such adjustments, China’s economic growth trajectory will continue at the expense of U.S. economic sustainability and global competitiveness. Americans may want to consider manufacturing these products domestically for US consumption. Remember, the global tariff game is like a chess match; you must balance losses against wins.